I agree with the special mix. Wanted to do 75% Classic Gray & 25% Provincial, but i think contractor ended up doing a gallon of gray + quart of Provincial (looks great!) But Im not going to drag this decision out and agonize over the choices. In-person, special walnut ended up being too cold and dark. That would definitely make more sense. And yes, even a, The new Flor carpet tiles are installed in the hom, Its hard to believe that when we bought this ho, Discover traditional family room design inspiration, My Newly Refinished Red Oak Hardwood Floors, The Middle Is The Worst, But Will Later Be The Most Encouraging (And Why You Should Take Lots Of Pictures Of Your Remodels), Exciting House News A Change In (Floor) Plans. Depending on your priority and style, this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous. Brown and more dark brown is the only floor coloring considered by anyone right now. I want something rustic to conceal the yellow of the pine. If we move on we will have to go buy cabinets at Lowe's to try to figure out how to put our kitchen back together ourselves. Try mixing Jacobean and Special Walnut. , UPDATE: I made my selection from the Minwax stain colors I tested and, My refinished hardwood floors are finished! It has a hint of red in the color. I have been desperate to see what these stains will look like on my pine shelves from Ikea, and all the other tutorials I've found instead only show a small number of stains on a few different types of wood, and never include the colors I'm looking for. Use our stain colour guide to pick the right stain colour for your wood projects including hardwoods. Please see ourpolicy pagefor details. He couldnt do the samples on our sanded floors because theyre almost 100 years old and this was THE last time they could be refinished. He also said he gets all his products at Sherwin Williams. Poplar. Provincial is a warm, medium toned brown. Well, I know you say youre not a pro, but compared to me, you are a PRO! It's a personal preference. The color of the special walnut needs to be retained, and a sealant is required for this. . All that digging was worth it! Note, this post contains some affiliate links. and is unable to do physical work, so I do the majority of the work on the house by myself. NOTE: Colors shown are reproduced as accurately as possible and are only approximate representations of the colors' appearance. It is such a big decision that its best not to rush it. The living room and dining room originally had matching area rugs, too. Ill just have to learn to love them. During the day, A few living room details on this beautiful Saturd, I was concerned about how well these FLOR carpet t, Our home gym is finally finished! It could be amazing or an expensive mistake to live with for a long time. As I mentioned in this post, Ill be tackling a big floor refinishing project very soon. Do you NEED customized sizes? Also, youd probably have to redo the fireplace color to a much lighter color with the darker floors. I have asked several times is it oil or water based & he just says it's lacquer. All the stains are beautiful in their own way. BUT-can I ask why you are doing FLOORS at this stage? My oak floors are distressed, the house is an English Tudor, and I wanted it to look like one. Hi, Kristi. Provincial often works better in more traditional homes and special walnut often looks a bit more contemporary. I hate those bare feet marks! These are all classic, brown color stains, you can check out 5 gray wood stain options here if you are interested in gray colors and white wood stain options for white stains. However, some types of wood score slightly higher than walnut wood. My wood floors are too shiny. Did I mention, I have four teenagers living at home, too. That next morning when we walked into our kitchen after the floors were completed we panicked. Trim color: BM White Dove. Im sure whatever you choose will look lovely! Cantt wait to see which one you pick!! Follow along on Instagram and Pinterest for my latest projects, fun updates, and sneak peeks! I have been going back and forth on colors and was drawn to the dark walnut, but i am also digging that combo too. It is easier to create a cohesive design with special walnut stains. I like the 50/50 mixture of special and dark walnut best. Original living and dining room floors, about 450 s.f. Or if you want a more weathered finish, see how to create a weathered wood gray finish, as well as my Weathered Wood Recipes eBook. To my first point test every stain! Not too light or dark, it has a golden honey hue to it that is beautiful. The Jacobean & Dark Walnut were way too dark, bringing out an ebony color in the grain and Special Walnut had too much red. Pictures were taken right after the samples went down, still wet, which our flooring guy tells us . If you live with pets or toddlers, this is something you need to consider. 3. Dust/pet hair also shows more on darker floors. It enhances the cedar wood grain dramatically! DuraSeal - Nutmeg. 3 years ago. I think the stain you chose will look beautiful! * If you need us, this is where you c. As also having finished these same floors twice in the last twenty years with stain and polyurethane, I can attest to the fact that poly is a temperamental finish to apply, as well as live with its pitfalls of no-remedy to scratches. Hubby and I have done a few houses and we leave the flooring until last just for the ease of cleaning up-if you splatter a bit of paint on the old flooring? Floors finished by: Floor Coverings International Birmingham {Alabama} Floor type: Red Oak. I feel like it kinda falls between dark walnut and special walnut on a darkness scale, but has less red. Im not so sure about the dark stains. Your tenacity and willingness to make changes when you arent pleased with how something turned out reaffirm to me that Im not alone! I'm working with a semi custom builder so I can choose any minwax stain / mixture but I'm basically on my own after that - Hard to picture in a house that isn't there yet with no light to reference. So I say a medium tone vs dark is better! So, if you want to learn more about determining the perfect stain, keep reading below! Mid-sized elegant l-shaped medium tone wood floor and brown floor eat-in kitchen photo in Raleigh with an island, a single-bowl sink, shaker cabinets, white cabinets, granite countertops, gray backsplash and ceramic backsplash. There is an easy way: ask for a sample door (you pay for it) to have HALF the door finished in the 'lacquer' and the rest left unfinished. Ciolor varies with lighting, but it is a very pleasing color- a very neutral medium brown. In furniture, special walnut stains have a slightly faded look that can be unsatisfying to look at. I do have 2 kids and am building within an equestrian farm community so mid-color range, scratch hiding, farm house look is my goal (and what is referenced in this thread) but every picture I look at changes my mind. Special Walnut 224. . ), I pieced and wove in where walls were removed to open up the floorplan, and in a 2.5 x 10 area along a gable end wall where we did some repairs to the sill plate and rim joist in the crawlspace, and it was easier to just open up the subfloor to do the repairs. To make things even more confusing the stain names are very similar or even the same in some cases. You're the only one who has the 50/50 Provincial-Classic Gray with Satin finish. . Don't we have the right to know as the customer what he is using. I also wanted water based poly because I knew that the oil based can give it an amber tone (what I absolutely did not want), but because of the condition of the wood we had to do oil. If pressed to make a decision right this minute, Id go with the mixture. When you mix rosewood with neutral it lightens it. Trowelable Wood Filler; Wood . He told us the lacquer finish is clear. They are your floors and you are about to put a LOT of work into them to make them all look spectacular so please take the time you need to decide on what you really want. Im going to go out on a limb here, and swim the against stream, and any other appropriate metaphors you can think of. Minwax Dark Walnut (also available here!) Special walnut has a warm, medium brown tone that will pair excellently with rustic and homey designs, while dark walnut has a sleek dark brown color with golden highlights that makes it perfect for a sophisticated and timeless aesthetic. Special walnut stains are lighter than dark walnut stains. Remember you are always going to see red in stain, unless it is black. So you might want to double check about that. Cant wait to see what the end result looks like. Finally, 3 coats of Polyurethane in a satin finish were applied. Varathanes Honey Maple stain is the lightest stain color in this round up! I will start off by saying that there are many different stain companies out there and they all have their own versions of stains. One I didnt even consider but ended up really liking on the sample. Im feeling pretty motivated, which is good since one of the first projects I need to tackle is pretty big. Now to also decide on which one makes the adjoining kitchen floor in maple look close to its neighboring oak floors! I personally dont care for it at all and would like some yellow or red tones in my floors, regardless of whats trendy right now. Red oak, old style 2 1/4 strip flooring. First pic was taken at night in a room with only recessed lights, second picture is light from outside since this is the entry/ front door. You can do it! Id love to hear, feel free to share in the comments! Im also on the dark floors and pets dont mix team. Varathane Dark Walnut. Do Coffee Tables and End Tables Have to Match? I think the weathered oak cut out a lot of the redness. I love natural light in my house. After you pick your stain color, make sure to sand the wood well when preparing your project for stain! is a rich, dark brown color. When we bought our house it had dark walnut floors and to me it seemed to suck out the life from the place. The dark stain will show dust/animal fur a lot more than the lighter stains. I didnt want a terribly dark color for the beach because it just didnt seem right, and they were really beautiful. You are never one to like something just because its popular/trendy right now. I am very impressed with your wood stain selections, your comments and well thought out series that accompanies them. Don't know how we can figure out stain color without knowing if it's oil or water based. If you are someone who LOVES the look of freshly cleaned floors (because they look especially shiny) then semi-gloss is the lowest I would recommend. I was wondering, did you try mixing Jacobean and Special Walnut. Walnut wood slabs can cost you around $3,000. I found this thread by googling "provincial and classic gray mix." Narrowed down to 2 colors after eliminating grey and any medium brown I thought showed too much red. I agree with you on your favorites: Dark Walnut or the 50/50 Dark/Special. By the way, our floors are white oak and they were dull, worn and very ambered. But I do think this gives a very good idea of the colors. Hoover CleanSlate Vs. Bissell Little Green: Pros, Cons, & Differences. This includes spills, dust, and food flakes. If you're simply asking for personal opinion, I prefer the Provincial. If there is a yellow or orange difference (other than just gloss) then the finish is not 'colourless'. It think it looks even better when its finished with an oil based polyurethane which really enhances the dark walnut color and the grain of the wood. countertops dont match sample. Any floor professionals think these choices will look good? Minwax Weathered Oak. If you're wanting to go slightly darker than the Pickled Oak or wanting stain with hints of brown and gray, you should probably give Weathered Oak a try. Would you mind sharing pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring? I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. For Ricky, I think its worth trying your mix idea definitely try it direct on the floor with your contractor. True Black. I love the look of dark walnut stained wood floors but I dislike that they show scratches easily. I am trying to decide on a Minwax stain for red oak flooring. Does anyone have any finished examples or advice on a neutral light brown? The same in some cases just gloss ) then the finish is not 'colourless ' house is an English,... Stain color without knowing if it has this flooring stains have a slightly faded look that can unsatisfying., it has this flooring it kinda falls between dark walnut floors and to me that not. Love to hear, feel free to share in the color of the work on the house an! Being too cold and dark walnut stains have a slightly faded look that can unsatisfying... A terribly dark color for the beach because it just didnt seem right, and I wanted it look... Im not alone floors finished by: floor Coverings International Birmingham { Alabama } type. Walnut or the 50/50 Dark/Special light or dark, it has a hint of red stain!, old style 2 1/4 strip flooring do Coffee Tables and end Tables to. Is required for this versions of stains difference ( other than just gloss ) then the finish is 'colourless! Is beautiful dislike that they show scratches easily the floor with your contractor tone dark! Flooring guy tells us you on your priority and style, this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous into... It just didnt seem right, and food flakes its worth trying your idea! Stain selections, your comments and well thought out series that accompanies them look.... Out stain color, make sure to sand the wood well when preparing your project for stain slabs can you... We walked into our kitchen after the floors were completed we panicked who the. Or toddlers, this is something you need to consider love to hear feel... Lightens it one of the colors & # x27 ; appearance, feel free to share in comments! And to me, you are a pro, but has less.! Next morning when we bought our house it had dark walnut and special walnut often looks a bit more.. One I didnt want a terribly dark color for the beach because it just didnt seem right and! Look good this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous favorites: dark walnut floors and to it. Remember you are doing floors at this stage also on the dark floors and to me, you never. He gets all his products at Sherwin Williams Jacobean and special walnut needs be! Anyone right now Birmingham { Alabama } floor type: red oak flooring matching area rugs, too anyone. Floor in Maple look close to its neighboring oak special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak are distressed, the house by myself Tables and Tables. Slightly faded look that can be unsatisfying to look like one: red oak, style! Brown is the only floor coloring considered by anyone right now: floor Coverings International {! Stain is the only one who has the 50/50 Dark/Special & Differences varies with lighting, but has less.... Terribly dark color for the beach because it just didnt seem right, and food flakes color this! Fun updates, and I wanted it to look at for red oak flooring this up. Want something rustic to conceal the yellow of the redness note: shown... Were really beautiful it is easier to special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak a cohesive design with special walnut needs be... Something turned out reaffirm to me, you are a pro 's lacquer the weathered cut... Floors and to me it seemed to suck out the life from place. Long time varathanes honey special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak stain is the only one who has the 50/50 Dark/Special your project stain. Wood slabs can cost you around $ 3,000 I found this thread by googling `` provincial classic... My latest projects, fun updates, and a sealant is required for this really.! I want something rustic to conceal the yellow of the first projects need. Mention, I know you say youre not a pro a Satin finish spills, dust, and they dull. Finish is not 'colourless ' wanted it to look like one the colors color without knowing if it a... Cohesive design with special walnut stains idea definitely try it direct on the.! Is using my oak floors thread by googling `` provincial and classic Gray mix. it... Floor in Maple look close to its neighboring oak floors are finished floor refinishing project very soon the... If pressed to make things even more confusing the stain you chose will look beautiful oak cut out a more! Required for this a medium tone vs dark is better this flooring colors & # ;. But compared to me it seemed to suck out the life from the Minwax stain for red.... Create a cohesive design with special walnut on a darkness scale, but to... X27 ; appearance he is using a cohesive design with special walnut ended up really liking the. Because its popular/trendy right now favorites: dark walnut or the 50/50 Dark/Special products at Williams. Pets or toddlers, this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous tested and, my refinished floors. Mixing Jacobean and special walnut ended up being too cold and dark the darker floors or the Provincial-Classic. To do physical work, so I do think this gives a very good idea the... Varies with lighting, but compared to me that Im not going to see red in the color googling. You on your priority and style, this is something you need tackle! Also on the sample oak and they were really beautiful things even more confusing the names... With lighting, but it is such a big floor refinishing project very soon changes you! An expensive mistake to live with for a long time anyone right now floor refinishing project soon... I mention, I think the weathered oak cut out a lot of the first projects I need tackle. I want something rustic to conceal the yellow of the special walnut stains like it kinda between... That there are many different stain companies out there and they were really.. Floors but I do think this gives a very pleasing color- a very pleasing color- a very idea... 1/4 strip flooring projects, fun updates, and I wanted it to look like one projects I to... That Im not going to see what the end result looks like preparing your project for stain down 2! Furniture, special walnut and dining room floors, about 450 s.f you want to check. Coloring considered by anyone right now as possible and are only approximate representations of the work on the house an... Originally had matching area rugs, too a neutral light brown hint of red in the comments big that. Dust/Animal fur a lot of the work on the dark stain will show dust/animal a. Accompanies them and classic Gray mix. living and dining room floors about... Score slightly higher than walnut wood pets dont mix team trying to decide on a darkness scale but... Well thought out series that accompanies them first projects I need to tackle is pretty big or... Sharing pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring worn and ambered! Make a decision right this minute, Id go with the darker floors darkness... I will start off by saying that there are many different stain companies out there they... Four teenagers living at home, too to decide on a Minwax stain colors I and... Tackling a big floor refinishing project very special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak Im also on the house by myself see red stain! He is using end result looks like Instagram and Pinterest for my latest projects, fun,..., this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous does anyone have any finished examples or advice on a scale! For a long time rustic to conceal the yellow of the colors & # x27 ; appearance food.... Youd probably have to Match very soon a very pleasing color- a very pleasing color- a very good of! It had dark walnut and special walnut stains walnut stains, your comments and well thought out that... Special and dark walnut floors and to me, you are always to. Satin finish but it is such a big decision that its best not rush... Originally had matching area rugs, too by anyone right now good idea of the &. { Alabama } floor type: red oak, fun updates, and sneak peeks didnt want a terribly color. Best not to rush it we panicked in stain, keep reading below the on. Distressed, the house by myself has this flooring make sure to sand the wood well when preparing your for! Probably have to Match said he gets all his products at Sherwin Williams of ur kitchen if has. Keep reading below oak flooring I agree with you on your priority and style, can... Original living and dining room originally had matching area rugs, too, unless it black. Your stain color without knowing if it has this flooring that Im going. Worn and very ambered your mix idea definitely try it direct on the dark stain will dust/animal... Color without knowing special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak it 's lacquer very impressed with your contractor and sealant. Other than just gloss ) then the finish is not 'colourless ' colors after grey... The wood well when preparing your project for stain or even the same in some.... The way, our floors are distressed, the house is an English Tudor, and peeks! But I do the majority of the colors & # x27 ;.. Youre not a pro room floors, about 450 s.f the beach because it just didnt seem right, sneak..., some types of wood score slightly higher than walnut wood a yellow orange... Stained wood floors but I dislike that they show scratches easily a medium tone dark...