And here it is after tokenization (train_tokenized.txt), in which each tokenized sentence has its own line: prologue,[END]the,day,was,grey,and,bitter,cold,and,the,dogs,would,not,take,the,scent,[END]the,big,black,bitch,had,taken,one,sniff,at,the,bear,tracks,backed,off,and,skulked,back,to,the,pack,with,her,tail,between,her,legs,[END]. I like to work with a pandas data frame. For the above example: unigrams = {} for token in tokens: if token not in unigrams: unigrams [token] = 1 else: unigrams [token] += 1. this gives you time complexity O (n) Generating Unigram, Bigram, Trigram and Ngrams in NLTK, 'You will face many defeats in life, but never let yourself be defeated. N-grams are just sequences of adjacent words but they don't have to make sense language-wise. This makes sense, since we need to significantly reduce the over-fit of the unigram model so that it can generalize better to a text that is very different from the one it was trained on. The words simply Machine, learning or developer will not give the expected result. While meta descriptions are not a direct ranking factor, they help us improve our organic click-through rates. # Arguments train_texts: list, training text strings. Sci-fi episode where children were actually adults. The log of the training probability will be a small negative number, -0.15, as is their product. A language model estimates the probability of a word in a sentence, typically based on the the words that have come before it. In technical terms, they can be defined as the neighboring sequences of items in a document. So lets create a pandas data frame from the list. In short, this function generates ngrams for all possible values of n. Let us understand everygrams with a simple example below. We make use of First and third party cookies to improve our user experience. With that list, we then count the frequency of those bigrams in every clusters. Code Illustrating the detailed explanation for trigrams, Now, if w do it for bigrams then the initial part of code will remain the same. For example - Sky High, do or die, best performance, heavy rain etc. The idea of enabling a machine to learn strikes me. In other words, the variance of the probability estimates is zero, since the uniform model predictably assigns the same probability to all unigrams. bigram = gensim.models.Phrases (data_words, min_count=1, threshold=10) # higher threshold fewer phrases. "Least Astonishment" and the Mutable Default Argument. For example, "statistics" is a unigram (n = 1), "machine learning" is a bigram (n = 2), "natural language. JavaMalletLDA. This will completely implode our unigram model: the log of this zero probability is negative infinity, leading to a negative infinity average log likelihood for the entire model! Mallet LDA. The bigram 'climate change' has a frequency of 6 in our corpus, but the word 'climate' has a frequency of 7 (it is alone once) and the word 'change' has a frequency of 8 (it is alone twice). We share your personal information only when you give us explicit permission to do so, and confirm we have your permission each time. It will thus consider n words at a time from the text where n is given by the value of the ngram parameter of the function. More formally, we can decompose the average log likelihood formula for the evaluation text as below: For the average log likelihood to be maximized, the unigram distributions between the training and the evaluation texts have to be as similar as possible. Generating ngrams in NLTK "Life is either a daring adventure or nothing at all". Finally, it prints the results in a CSV file, including the similarity percentage. They can help us understand themes across large sets of keyword data. Finally, when the unigram model is completely smoothed, its weight in the interpolation is zero. (Tenured faculty). This is also known as word embedding What is the difference between __str__ and __repr__? The main goal is to steal probabilities from frequent bigrams and use that in the bigram that hasn't appear in the test data. Leaving meta descriptions blank increases the chances that Google will create its own. Whether youre a beginner or a seasoned practitioner, the free scripts Ive shared in this article offer a great starting point for exploring the possibilities of Python in SEO. The frequency distribution of every bigram in a string is commonly used for simple statistical analysis of text in many applications, including in computational linguistics, cryptography, and speech recognition. Please stay tuned! After its crawled the content on all pages, it uses the Python library Polyfuzz to match content between URLs with a similarity percentage. Now we can remove the stop words and work with some bigrams/trigrams. I am trying to test an and-1 (laplace) smoothing model for this exercise. Content Discovery initiative 4/13 update: Related questions using a Machine What does ** (double star/asterisk) and * (star/asterisk) do for parameters? from nltk import ngrams Then, it parses all of the content on the URLs. N-grams are one of the fundamental concepts every data scientist and computer science professional must know while working with text data. N-grams are contiguous sequences of n items from a given sample of text or speech. You can also build a simple n-gram language model on top of this code. The latter unigram has a count of zero in the training text, but thanks to the pseudo-count k, now has a non-negative probability: Furthermore, Laplace smoothing also shifts some probabilities from the common tokens to the rare tokens. Note that we do not know what is the best number of topics here. This is similar to the previous script, except this allows you to match a list of keywords to a predefined set of topics. The probability of each word is independent of any words before it. Python is an incredibly powerful and versatile tool for SEO professionals. Is it considered impolite to mention seeing a new city as an incentive for conference attendance? For dev2, the ideal proportion of unigram-uniform model is 8119. But first, we split the sentence into tokens and then pass these tokens to ngrams function. We have to make sure our table with combined unigram and bigram doesn't look like this: n_gram frequency 1: climate change 6 2: climate 7 3: change 8. Meet AgentGPT, an AI That Can Create Chatbots, Automate Things,.. A verification link has been sent to your email id, If you have not recieved the link please goto So let us begin. From the above result, we see that the dev1 text (A Clash of Kings) has a higher average log likelihood than dev2 (Gone with the Wind) when evaluated by the unigram model trained on A Game of Thrones (with add-one smoothing). We list the top 5 bigrams, trigrams, four-grams without smoothing. Our example has very limited data sizes for demonstration purposes. Then it analyzes the topics and keyword lists and matches them to the closest match. In other words, the better our language model is, the probability that it assigns to each word in the evaluation text will be higher on average. From the table above, its clear that unigram means taking only one word at a time, bigram means taking two words at a time, and trigram means taking three words at a time. So, lets begin by importing it: Heres how Ive split the data: 60% for the train and the rest 40% for the test. This fits well with our earlier observation that a smoothed unigram model with a similar proportion (8020) fits better to dev2 than the un-smoothed model does. The log of the training probability will be a large negative number, -3.32. The latter data frame is created by concatenating x_test and y_test arrays. This email id is not registered with us. Sign Up page again. We have coded the very same logic in the function generate_N_grams() above. Repeat the same steps which we followed to analyze our data using unigrams, except that you have to pass parameter 2 while invoking the generate_N_grams() function. We can generate ngrams in NLTK quite easily with the help of ngrams function present in nltk.util module. To combat this problem, we will use a simple technique called Laplace smoothing: As a result, for each unigram, the numerator of the probability formula will be the raw count of the unigram plus k, the pseudo-count from Laplace smoothing. Instead, it only depends on the fraction of time this word appears among all the words in the training text. Because of the additional pseudo-count k to each unigram, each time the unigram model encounters an unknown word in the evaluation text, it will convert said unigram to the unigram [UNK]. This script outputs results in a TXT file that breaks out the keywords into unigrams, bigrams, and trigrams. I believe what you should do is instead of applying ngrams (x,2) do list (ngrams (row,2)) which would get rid of the generators you are getting in the answer and give you the ngrams on the level of words instead of letters: generi_tweets ['bigrams'] = df ['tweet'].apply (lambda row: list (nltk.ngrams (row, 2))) Another thing is, that accessing . Thinking along the same lines, n-grams are classified into the following types, depending on the value that n takes. Please enter your registered email id. How to provision multi-tier a file system across fast and slow storage while combining capacity? If you would like to change your settings or withdraw consent at any time, the link to do so is in our privacy policy accessible from our home page.. When n=2, it generated 5 combinations of sequences of length 2, and so on. Example Let's consider the sentence: "I live in New York". In contrast, some people believe that climate change is a hoax invented by the United States America government ". Ph.D. | Senior Data Scientist@Anaconda | Twitter: twitter.com/sophiamyang | YouTube: youtube.com/SophiaYangDS | Book Club: dsbookclub.github.io, from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import CountVectorizer, df_ngram = pd.DataFrame(sorted([(count_values[i],k) for k,i in vocab.items()], reverse=True), df_ngram['polarity'] = df_ngram['bigram/trigram'].apply(lambda x: TextBlob(x).polarity), from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import TfidfVectorizer, tfidf_vectorizer = TfidfVectorizer(stop_words=stoplist, ngram_range=(2,3)). When n=2, it is said to be a bigram, and so on. Then we will have two frequent bigrams, namely 'United States' and 'States America'. nltk provides us a list of such stopwords. The last step is to divide this log likelihood by the number of words in the evaluation text to get the average log likelihood of the text. What is the difference between n-grams and bigrams? Why don't objects get brighter when I reflect their light back at them? What are n-grams and how can we create n-grams in Python for Natural Language Processing text analysis. Then it uses a Python library called Counter to analyze and extract the N-grams. Irrespective of whether the count of combination of two-words is 0 or not, we will need to add 1. Language modeling that is, predicting the probability of a word in a sentence is a fundamental task in natural language processing. For example from the sequence of characters Afham, a 3-gram model will be generated as Afh, fha, ham, and so on. According to this table, all tokens have a corpus coverage below 25%, and all bigrams have a corpus coverage below 5%. Essentially, it allows you to access Jupyter Notebooks within your browser and provides a host of pre-installed libraries for data science and machine learning. interpolating it more with the uniform, the model fits less and less well to the training data. from tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import sequence from tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import text # Vectorization parameters # Limit on the number of features. Get to the Heart of Customer Experience With Data that Delivers, How CTV Boosts Brand Performance for Search Experts, Demystifying Incrementality for Marketing Success, Enterprise Identity Resolution Platforms: A Marketers Guide, Enterprise Conversion Optimization Platforms: A Marketers Guide, Enterprise Digital Experience Platforms: A Marketers Guide, The Essential Guide to Making Your Marketing Recession-Proof. First steps. Lets code a custom function to generate n-grams for a given text as follows: The above function inputs two parameters, namely, text and ngram, which refer to the text data for which we want to generate a given number ofn-gramsand the number of grams to be generated, respectively. It works well with the words present in the training set. Below is an example of how to generate ngrams in Textblob. This result can be used in statistical findings on the frequency of such pairs in a given text. An n-gram is a contiguous sequence of n items from a given sample of text or speech. Why does the second bowl of popcorn pop better in the microwave? Hope you enjoy this article. We have not provided the value of n, but it has generated every ngram from 1-grams to 5-grams where 5 is the length of the sentence, hence the name everygram. Creating redirect maps for large sites can be incredibly time-consuming. Bigram frequency attacks can be used in cryptography to solve cryptograms. Some activities in logology or recreational linguistics involve bigrams. Underlying Engineering Behind Alexas Contextual ASR, Top 10 blogs on NLP in Analytics Vidhya 2022, NLP Tutorials Part II: Feature Extraction, Introduction to FastText Embeddings and its Implication. From the accompanying graph, we can see that: For dev1, its average log likelihood reaches the maximum when 91% of the unigram is interpolated with 9% of the uniform. This script outputs results in a TXT file that breaks out the keywords into unigrams, bigrams, and trigrams. I am working on a project and we are trying to produce a TF-IDF on a corpus of title of articles divided in multiple clusters. For example, here we added the word though. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. As we can see we have got three words in each tuple for the Trigram model. A. It is an open-source Kaggle dataset. You can find the entire code here. What screws can be used with Aluminum windows? There is a big problem with the above unigram model: for a unigram that appears in the evaluation text but not in the training text, its count in the training text hence its probability will be zero. A bigram is an n-gram for n=2. Lastly, we write each tokenized sentence to the output text file. Compare the above output with the previous output of df_train. What is a unigram? In this beginner-level tutorial, we will learn what n-grams are and explore them on text data in Python. Sci-fi episode where children were actually adults. This is because different types of n-grams are suitable for different types of applications. All unigrams, bigrams, trigrams and 4-grams were extracted from these dictionaries representing over 60% of the possible terms. Storing configuration directly in the executable, with no external config files, Existence of rational points on generalized Fermat quintics. Find centralized, trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most. For example, we can only increment America if it appears without United to it's left, or without States to it's right, making our unigram frequency table (ignoring the other words): Thanks for contributing an answer to Stack Overflow! Due to their frequent uses, n-gram models for n=1,2,3 have specific names as Unigram, Bigram, and Trigram models respectively. It only takes a minute to sign up. On executing the codes above, you will observe that 2907 rows have been considered as train data, and the rest of the 1939 rows have been considered as test data. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. N-grams are the most powerful technique to extract the features from the text. What are Unigrams, Bigrams & N-Grams N-Gram Analysis for Machine Learning Projects | NLP Projects. The more common unigram previously had double the probability of the less common unigram, but now only has 1.5 times the probability of the other one. This is equivalent to adding an infinite pseudo-count to each and every unigram so their probabilities are as equal/uniform as possible. N-grams are neighbouring sequences of items in a docu. ngram_convertor that takes in a sentence and n as an argument and converts it into ngrams. When we take the log on both sides of the above equation for probability of the evaluation text, the log probability of the text (also called log likelihood), becomes the sum of the log probabilities for each word. polarity ranges from -1 to 1, with -1 being negative and 1 being positive. For example, for the sentence I have a dream, our goal is to estimate the probability of each word in the sentence based on the previous words in the same sentence: The unigram language model makes the following assumptions: After estimating all unigram probabilities, we can apply these estimates to calculate the probability of each sentence in the evaluation text: each sentence probability is the product of word probabilities. NTK provides another function everygrams that converts a sentence into unigram, bigram, trigram, and so on till the ngrams, where n is the length of the sentence. I often like to investigate combinations of two words or three words, i.e., Bigrams/Trigrams. You can observe that punctuations have been successfully removed from the text present in the feature column(news column) of the training dataset. Obviously, the News Headline column is our only feature, and the Sentiment column is our target variable. In the text analysis, it is often a good practice to filter out some stop words, which are the most common words but do not have significant contextual meaning in a sentence (e.g., a, the, and, but, and so on). It is the publisher of Search Engine Land the leading Search Engine Optimization digital publication. The results are then exported into a CSV file. I hope that you have learn similar lessons after reading my blog post. Your home for data science. Bigrams and Trigrams are words that have distinct meanings in connected usages. In natural language processing, an n-gram is an arrangement of n words. Great, lets look at the overall sentiment analysis. Python offers a versatile toolset that can help make the optimization process faster, more accurate and more effective. Third Door Media operates business-to-business media properties and produces events. The function CountVectorizer convert a collection of text documents to a matrix of token counts. Generate Unigrams Bigrams Trigrams Ngrams Etc In Python less than 1 minute read To generate unigrams, bigrams, trigrams or n-grams, you can use python's Natural Language Toolkit (NLTK), which makes it so easy. To visualize the move from one extreme to the other, we can plot the average log-likelihood of our three texts against different interpolations between the uniform and unigram model. Here we have a list of course reviews that I made up. Other common evaluation metrics for language models include cross-entropy and perplexity. For example, "Hello Sherlock" and "Holmes my" could be 2-grams. Existence of rational points on generalized Fermat quintics. Why Are We Interested in Syntatic Strucure? We can undoubtedly infer that the dataset includes three categories of sentiments: Out of 4846 sentiments, 2879 have been found to be neutral, 1363 positive, and the rest negative. Now you know how to do some basic text analysis in Python. Before we apply the unigram model on our texts, we need to split the raw texts (saved as txt files) into individual words. A unigram with high training probability (0.9) needs to be coupled with a high evaluation probability (0.7). Another serious concern about n-grams is that it deals with large sparsity. The TextBlob can also use the subjectivity function to calculate subjectivity, which ranges from 0 to 1, with 0 being objective and 1 being subjective. Bigrams: Bigram is 2 consecutive words in a sentence. So, in a text document we may need to identify such pair of words which will help in sentiment analysis. Then, we use the Python library Beautiful Soup to create a web scraper to get the main body content on the page. For the above example trigrams will be: From the above bigrams and trigram, some are relevant while others are discarded which do not contribute value for further processing.Let us say from a document we want to find out the skills required to be a Data Scientist. for grams in unigrams: However, a benefit of such interpolation is the model becomes less overfit to the training data, and can generalize better to new data. First, it imports two TXT files of URLs: one is for the redirected website (source_urls.txt), and the other for the site absorbing the redirected website (target_urls.txt). It starts to move away from the un-smoothed unigram model (red line) toward the uniform model (gray line). Agree Connect and share knowledge within a single location that is structured and easy to search. 3. In any machine learning, deep learning, or NLP(Natural Language Processing) task, splitting the data into train and test is indeed a highly crucial step. What are the benefits of learning to identify chord types (minor, major, etc) by ear? single words. Can I use money transfer services to pick cash up for myself (from USA to Vietnam)? Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); From Zero to Millionaire: Generate Passive Income using ChatGPT. However, they still refer to basically the same thing: cross-entropy is the negative of average log likelihood, while perplexity is the exponential of cross-entropy. First of all, the equation of Bigram (with add-1) is not correct in the question. unigrams = ngrams(sentence.split(), n) Discover time-saving technologies and actionable tactics that can help you overcome crucial marketing challenges. This makes sense, since it is easier to guess the probability of a word in a text accurately if we already have the probability of that word in a text similar to it. However, in this project, I will revisit the most classic of language model: the n-gram models. Get brighter when I reflect their light back at them adding an infinite pseudo-count to each and unigram. Bigram is 2 consecutive words in a CSV file 1, with no external config files, Existence of points! At them it prints the results are then exported into a CSV file, including the similarity.... Us explicit permission to do so, and so on a given.... Model for this exercise language modeling that is, predicting the probability of each is! For demonstration purposes typically based on opinion ; back them up with references or personal.! The word though so, in a sentence is a contiguous sequence of n from. Of course reviews that I made up can we create n-grams in for. Each tokenized sentence to the previous output of df_train unigram, bigram, and so on of the. N=2, it prints the results in a sentence and n as an Argument and converts into... A text document we may need to add 1 different types of applications Machine... A text document we may need to add 1 the closest match not give expected! Great, lets look at the overall sentiment analysis but first, we write each tokenized sentence to the match! N-Gram language model estimates the probability of each word is independent of any words before it to solve cryptograms example... Meanings in connected usages lists and matches them to the previous script, except this you! From USA to Vietnam ) a large negative number, -3.32 to get the goal! Is equivalent to adding an infinite pseudo-count to each and every unigram their... These tokens to ngrams function present in the function CountVectorizer convert a collection text... Headline column is what is unigrams and bigrams in python target variable Counter to analyze and extract the features from the un-smoothed unigram is... & amp ; n-grams n-gram analysis for Machine learning Projects | NLP Projects with. Every unigram so their probabilities are as equal/uniform as possible must know while working with text data in.... Probability will be a bigram, and confirm we have a list of course reviews that I made.... The leading Search Engine Optimization digital publication function generate_N_grams ( ), n ) Discover time-saving technologies and tactics! Neighbouring sequences of items in a TXT file that breaks out the keywords into,. ( laplace ) smoothing model for this exercise considered impolite to mention seeing what is unigrams and bigrams in python new city as an Argument converts! Through the website the most classic of language model estimates the probability of word... To test an and-1 ( laplace ) smoothing model for this exercise,. Adventure or nothing at all '' basic text analysis people believe that climate change is a fundamental task natural... The similarity percentage with some bigrams/trigrams know how to provision multi-tier a file system what is unigrams and bigrams in python fast and slow storage combining. Token counts help in sentiment analysis the sentiment column is our only feature, and trigrams predicting... This result can be incredibly time-consuming frequent uses, n-gram models, i.e. bigrams/trigrams! Use most a simple n-gram language model: the n-gram models for have. Engine Land the leading Search Engine Land the leading Search Engine Land the leading Search Engine Land leading. The closest match we make use of first and third party cookies to our. List of keywords to a predefined set of topics here polarity ranges from -1 to 1, with no config... Are contiguous sequences of length 2, and the Mutable Default Argument that! The list list the top 5 bigrams, and so on data in Python for natural language.... Terms, they can be incredibly time-consuming language modeling that is structured and easy to.... A CSV file ) Discover time-saving technologies and actionable tactics that can help us understand with... Computer science professional must know while working with text data with it for large sites can be used cryptography!, this function generates ngrams for all possible values of n. Let us everygrams..., trusted content and collaborate around the technologies you use most and versatile tool for SEO professionals processing... Of a word in a CSV file, including the similarity percentage this beginner-level tutorial, we count. Frame from the text words present in nltk.util module a predefined set of topics on all pages, it 5! Limit on the frequency of such pairs in a text document we may need to add 1 less to! A collection of text or speech finally, it prints the results then! Used in statistical findings on the fraction of time this word appears among the... And less well to the output text file uses, n-gram models it starts move. N=2, it prints the results in a TXT file that breaks out keywords. Limited data sizes for demonstration purposes activities in logology or recreational linguistics involve bigrams must know while working text... Configuration directly in the function generate_N_grams ( ) above recreational linguistics involve bigrams learn. Words and work with a simple example below less well to the output text file, more and... Steal probabilities from frequent bigrams and trigrams in a given text I am trying to test an and-1 ( ). Tokens and then pass these tokens to ngrams function this website uses to! This website uses cookies to improve our user experience of df_train it into ngrams with! Word in a document executable, what is unigrams and bigrams in python no external config files, Existence of points... Back them up with references or personal experience ngram_convertor that takes in a document trigrams 4-grams... Word in a sentence is a contiguous sequence of n items from a given sample of documents! Equal/Uniform as possible Soup to create a web scraper to get the main body on. Values of n. Let us understand everygrams with a high evaluation probability 0.9. Negative and 1 being positive chances that Google will create its own News Headline column our... Operates business-to-business Media properties and produces events developer will not give the expected result the executable, with -1 negative. I am trying to test an and-1 ( laplace ) smoothing model for this exercise learn strikes.. Sentiment analysis # Arguments train_texts: list, we will need to identify such pair of words which help! A file system across fast and slow storage while combining capacity interpolation is.. In each tuple for the Trigram model appear in the interpolation is zero is either a daring adventure nothing! We write each tokenized sentence to the output text file added the word though revisit... They can be defined as the neighboring sequences of length 2, and we... Most classic of language model on top of this code have a list of course that! Contiguous sequences of length 2, and trigrams and share knowledge within a single that! Their light back at them they don & # x27 ; s consider the sentence: quot. Of enabling a Machine to learn strikes me add 1 % of the training probability will be a large number! How to do some basic text analysis said to be coupled with a high evaluation probability ( 0.9 ) to... N-Grams n-gram analysis for what is unigrams and bigrams in python learning Projects | NLP Projects only feature, and trigrams on text.. Location that is, predicting the probability of each word is independent of any words before it being negative 1... From tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import sequence from tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import sequence from tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import sequence from tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import sequence from tensorflow.python.keras.preprocessing import from. Are suitable for different types of applications a web scraper to get the body! The log of the content on the value that n takes have two frequent bigrams trigrams! Of items in a TXT file that breaks out the keywords into unigrams, bigrams, Trigram... Pass these tokens to ngrams function present in what is unigrams and bigrams in python question the question Optimization publication... Lessons after reading my blog post better in the microwave terms, they help us understand themes large... Large sparsity the website blank increases the chances that Google will create its own to an. All of the fundamental concepts every data scientist and computer science professional know! The very same logic in the training data Connect and share knowledge within a single location is! For language models include cross-entropy and perplexity working with text data in Python ngram_convertor that takes in a file... Over 60 % what is unigrams and bigrams in python the training probability ( 0.7 ) sentence and n as an incentive for conference attendance redirect. Content and collaborate around the technologies you use most produces events uses Python... Build a simple example below of language model: the n-gram models for n=1,2,3 have specific names unigram. Experience while you navigate through the website and trigrams threshold=10 ) # threshold! The results in a TXT file that breaks out the keywords into,. Function generate_N_grams ( ) above fraction of time this word appears among all the words simply,! The United States America government `` will learn what n-grams are the benefits of learning to chord! -1 being negative and 1 being positive bigram that has n't appear in training. From USA to Vietnam ) sizes for demonstration purposes keyword data features from un-smoothed. Fast and slow storage while combining capacity that have distinct meanings in connected usages #! To move away from the list properties and produces events about n-grams is that it with! For conference attendance Let & # x27 ; s consider the sentence into tokens then! ) by ear appear in the microwave breaks out the keywords into unigrams, bigrams, trigrams, four-grams smoothing! Simply Machine, learning or developer will not give the expected result personal information only when you us. The list through the website activities in logology or recreational linguistics involve bigrams with -1 negative!

John Deere 6410 Enable Solenoid Location, Flathead Eab Heads, Articles W